Slap a "nonpartisan" label next to the California State Controller and State Treasurer and you haven't fixed a single thing. You just handed voters a blank slate with zero guidance.
That is the lazy consensus floating around Sacramento op-ed pages right now. The standard pitch claims that because the controller and treasurer do not write tax laws, regulate abortion, or set policing policy, slapping a (D) or (R) next to their names is a distraction. Strip the labels, the argument goes, and voters will magically start judging candidates on spreadsheets, bond yields, and audit rigor. For a different view, check out: this related article.
Pure fantasy. It mistakes a ballot-box symptom for the real disease.
California's fiscal offices are not purely technical bookkeeping posts. They sit right inside political power centers that shape capital allocation, pension governance, and tax administration. Hiding party labels will not turn down-ballot voters into forensic accountants. It will just make an already opaque election even harder to read. Further reporting on the subject has been published by Reuters.
What the Op-Ed Crowd Misses About "Nonpartisan" Ballots
Reformers point to California's existing nonpartisan seats—like county supervisors, judges, and the Superintendent of Public Instruction—as proof that removing party cues elevates competence over tribalism.
Look at how those races actually play out.
When party labels disappear from a long, crowded ballot, voter drop-off spikes and low-information cues take over. Endorsements from organized labor, business coalitions, party clubs, and local mailers fill the vacuum. Often, those endorsements are the exact same partisan networks operating one step removed from the ballot line.
Even worse, removing the party label does not remove the politics. Consider what these two offices actually touch:
- State Controller: Serves on major state boards, including the Franchise Tax Board and public pension boards. How audits get prioritized, how local fiscal distress gets scrutinized, and how state accounting rules are enforced carry real political and economic weight.
- State Treasurer: Acts as the state's banker, overseeing bond issuance, debt management, and investment programs. Debt financing choices and capital priorities are never purely neutral—they reflect risk appetite, infrastructure strategy, and political trade-offs.
In statewide races, party affiliation is a blunt instrument. Nobody pretends (D) or (R) tells you everything about a candidate's fixed-income chops or internal-controls background. Yet eliminating a primary heuristic without replacing it with better voter information does not make voters more analytical. It makes them more reliant on name recognition, slate mailers, and institutional gatekeepers.
We Are Asking the Wrong Question About Fiscal Leadership
The debate over whether the controller and treasurer should run with party labels misses the deeper structural question: Why are we electing top state financial executives in a low-attention partisan general election in the first place?
Political scientists who study American state institutions—such as Thad Kousser on California governance and Morris Fiorina on accountability and electoral incentives—have long shown how institutional design shapes what voters can realistically monitor. When voters face a long list of down-ballot offices with little media coverage, accountability breaks down regardless of what sits in parentheses next to a name.
I have watched policy campaigns and ballot-reform pitches burn serious money chasing cosmetic fixes while ignoring governance mechanics. Changing a label on the ballot feels clean and modern. It requires no institutional heavy lifting. It also leaves the underlying incentive structure untouched.
Imagine a scenario where California passes a constitutional amendment tomorrow making the controller and treasurer nonpartisan. The (D) and (R) disappear from the November ballot. In the final weeks before election day, two candidates compete for low-information voters. One has a background in institutional asset management; the other has years of state legislative and political backing. Without a party cue on the ballot, voters still have to figure out who stands for what. Many will default to familiar names from higher-profile races, endorsees they recognize, or whichever campaign outspends the other in the final stretch.
Removing the label does not create fiscal literacy. It just shifts the battleground from a visible partisan cue to behind-the-scenes coalition signaling.
"People Also Ask" — Dismantled
Do the controller and treasurer actually make partisan policy decisions?
Not in the way legislators pass bills or governors sign budgets. Neither office sets income tax rates directly or writes criminal statutes. That part of the standard argument is true. What is false is the conclusion that their work is therefore apolitical. Managing trillions in cash flows, bond issuances, audits, and board seats involves real choices about risk, transparency, and institutional power.
Wouldn't nonpartisan elections help qualified finance professionals beat career politicians?
Not automatically. Voters still have to know who the finance professional is. In a massive state like California, credentials do not win low-salience races on their own. Money, endorsements, media visibility, and coalition backing do. A sharp portfolio manager or CPA can lose a nonpartisan race just as easily as a partisan one if voters never hear why their technical skills matter.
If nonpartisan labels aren't the answer, what actually improves fiscal accountability?
Start by being honest about what voters can realistically track. If California wants stronger financial stewardship, it should focus on clearer voter guides on actual job duties, stronger nonpartisan audit transparency, and clearer standards for financial expertise—not pretending that erasing a letter on the ballot transforms electoral behavior.
The Trade-Offs of Leaving the System Alone
Staying with partisan labels on the controller and treasurer ballots has real drawbacks.
Partisanship can turn technical offices into party-line rubber stamps in a state where one party holds a durable statewide advantage. Voters who only care about competent accounting or prudent bond management may feel boxed in by a partisan label. And candidates with strong technical records can get drowned out by national or gubernatorial polarization.
That trade-off is real. Still, a flawed signal is better than an absent signal when voters already lack time and coverage on down-ballot races.
What to Do Instead
If you care about California's fiscal health, stop treating ballot-label tinkering as reform:
- Judge candidates on institutional competence, not slogans. Look at actual experience with public budgets, audits, internal controls, or capital markets—not generic promises to "fix Sacramento."
- Track board seats, not just headlines. Pay attention to how a candidate approaches pension governance, tax administration, and debt issuance. That is where real leverage lives.
- Push for structural reform over cosmetic tweaks. If the goal is better financial governance, debate qualification standards, appointment vs. election trade-offs, and audit independence—things that actually change how the offices run.
Cosmetic ballot fixes make reformers feel virtuous. Real accountability takes harder work.