The High Price of Defending the Unforgivable

The High Price of Defending the Unforgivable

The notification arrives at two in the morning, glowing blue against a bedroom ceiling in Montreal. It is not a grade on a torts exam, nor is it an email from a study group. It is a message from a stranger promising violence, detailing exactly what should happen to a young woman who dared to speak up for a monster.

Her name is linked to a clinic at McGill University's Faculty of Law. His name is Jeffrey Ewert.

If you know the name Jeffrey Ewert, you likely feel a cold tightening in your stomach. In 1984, in British Columbia, Ewert committed crimes that defy easy comprehension—the murder and sexual assault of two women, alongside the attempted murder of another. He is a man whose past is written in blood and trauma, a person society decided long ago should never walk free again. For decades, he has sat behind the concrete and razor wire of Canadian federal prisons, an avatar of the worst things human beings can do to one another.

So when a law student—someone still learning the architecture of statutes, still carrying highlighters and heavy textbooks through the snowy streets of Quebec—stepped forward to represent him in a legal matter, the internet did not see a legal clinic at work. It saw a traitor.

The backlash was swift. Brutal. Unrelenting.

To understand why a twenty-something student found herself checking the locks on her apartment door after a routine legal assignment, we have to look past the headlines. We have to examine the widening fracture between how the law actually works and how the public wants it to feel. Because when we demand that certain people be stripped of an advocate, we aren't punishing the guilty. We are quietly dismantling the very shield that protects the innocent.

The Architecture of a Necessary Fiction

Let us step away from Montreal for a moment and consider a hypothetical scenario. Picture a small town where a horrific crime occurs. The evidence looks overwhelming. The town is furious, grieving, and desperate for someone to pay. The local authorities arrest a man—let’s call him Arthur. Arthur is unpleasant, strange, and entirely unsympathetic. Nobody likes him.

If the justice system operated on public sentiment, Arthur would be locked away before the ink dried on the arrest warrant. Why waste time? Why pay a lawyer to stand beside him and poke holes in the prosecutor's case?

Because the law is built on a specific, uncomfortable premise: the state is massive, and the individual is tiny. When the government decides to take away a person's liberty—or keep them locked in a cage forever—it must prove it has the legal authority to do so, every single time, without shortcuts.

I remember the first time I sat in the back of a criminal courtroom, watching a public defender argue over the admissibility of a search warrant for a client accused of violent assault. The courtroom smelled of floor wax and stale coffee. The victim's family sat two rows ahead of me, their shoulders rigid with rage. Watching that lawyer fight tooth and nail for a man who looked entirely guilty felt physically nauseating. It felt wrong. My gut screamed that the lawyer was helping a bad man get away with a bad thing.

It took years of watching the machinery of the courts grind forward to realize what that lawyer was actually doing. He wasn't defending the crime. He was defending the rulebook.

Think of the legal system like a suspension bridge. The cables holding it up are constitutional rights, procedural fairness, and the right to counsel. You don't test the strength of a suspension bridge on a sunny Tuesday when a single compact car drives across it. You test it during a hurricane, when a convoy of heavy trucks rolls over the deck at once. Jeffrey Ewert is the hurricane. He is the ultimate stress test for the Canadian legal system.

When a McGill law student represents someone like Ewert, she is not endorsing his 1984 murders. She is not asking the public to forgive him, forget his victims, or welcome him as a neighbor. Typically, prison law clinics deal with administrative fairness—things like whether Correctional Service Canada followed its own rules regarding security classifications, parole hearings, or psychological assessments. In fact, Ewert himself was at the center of a landmark 2018 Supreme Court of Canada ruling regarding the use of culturally biased psychological testing tools on Indigenous inmates. Even a man guilty of heinous crimes remains subject to the rule of law while in state custody. If prison officials can ignore the rules for Ewert simply because he is despised, nothing stops them from ignoring the rules for a wrongly convicted man sitting in the cell next to him.

When Empathy Becomes a Weapon

Why, then, does the public react with such visceral fury toward the messenger?

Part of the answer lies in a profound confusion between representation and endorsement. In our hyper-polarized digital culture, standing next to someone is treated as identical to standing with them. If you defend a politician, you are a partisan. If you critique a movie, you are a hater. And if you represent a convicted murderer, you must somehow approve of murder.

This confusion is fueled by a very real, very human emotion: grief.

When a case like Ewert's resurfaces in the news, the pain of the victims' families is torn open all over again. To a grieving relative, or to an empathetic bystander reading the news over morning coffee, the legal technicalities of prison administration look like an insult. They look like a murderer getting special attention, free legal help, and a platform, while his victims remain silent in the ground. That anger is deeply understandable. It is the natural human response to injustice.

Yet, somewhere between the news cycle and the comment section, that righteous grief mutates into something toxic.

Online outrage operates like a brushfire in dry timber. Outrage algorithms do not reward nuance; they reward certainty and rage. A nuanced explanation of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the duty of legal clinics gets three likes and is scrolled past in half a second. A screenshot of a student's face next to the mugshot of a double murderer gets shared ten thousand times in an hour.

Suddenly, a student who signed up for a legal clinic to learn how administrative law works is transformed into a villain. The threats begin. They arrive via email, on LinkedIn, on Instagram. Strangers who have never read a single page of the court docket feel entirely justified in wishing sexual violence or death upon a young woman because they believe they are striking a blow for justice.

The irony is suffocating. In the name of condemning a violent offender, the mob adopts the exact tools of terror and intimidation it claims to abhor.

The Invisible Chill

The immediate danger to the student is obvious—the sleepless nights, the anxiety of walking across campus, the sudden awareness of every stranger standing too close on the Metro. Institutions like McGill are forced to step in, offering security escorts and counseling, trying to shield a student from the fallout of doing the exact job her degree demands.

The deeper danger, however, is invisible. It is the chilling effect that settles over the next generation of lawyers.

Imagine you are a second-year law student watching this unfold. You have student loans, career ambitions, and a desire to live a peaceful life. You are looking at the course catalog for next semester, trying to decide which legal clinic to join. You see the prison law clinic, the refugee advocacy clinic, the criminal defense clinic.

And then you remember what happened to your classmate. You remember the doxxing. You remember the death threats. You remember how quickly the public turned on her, and how slow anyone outside the legal profession was to defend her.

Do you sign up? Or do you quietly check the box for corporate tax law instead?

This is how a justice system hollows itself out from the inside. Not through a dramatic coup or the repeal of a constitution, but through quiet intimidation. If the brightest, most empathetic young minds are terrorized out of taking unpopular cases, who is left to stand between the state and the accused?

Historically, the legal profession has relied on a principle known in Commonwealth jurisdictions as the "cab-rank rule"—the idea that just as a taxi driver at the front of a queue must take the next passenger regardless of who they are, a barrister must accept any client in their area of practice, regardless of how unpopular the client or their cause may be. While Canadian law students in clinics aren't bound by the strict British cab-rank rule, the ethical spirit remains identical. Every person has a right to a competent defense. Every person has a right to test the legality of their treatment by the state.

John Adams famously risked his career, his reputation, and his physical safety in 1770 to defend the British soldiers accused in the Boston Massacre. Colonial Boston wanted those soldiers hanged. Adams was reviled by his neighbors, his windows were broken, and his business suffered. Yet he stood in that courtroom anyway, arguing that facts are stubborn things, and that the law must remain deaf to the roar of the crowd. History remembers Adams not as a British sympathizer, but as a foundational pillar of American justice.

Today, we celebrate Adams in history books while sending death threats to the modern equivalents doing the exact same work in quiet university clinics.

The Courage of the Unpopular

It is easy to champion civil rights when the client is sympathetic. Everyone wants to defend the falsely accused teacher, the peaceful protester, or the wrongfully terminated nurse. Standing up for them costs nothing; in fact, it earns applause.

Rights, however, do not exist for the popular. The popular do not need constitutional protections, because the majority is already on their side. Rights exist specifically for the despised, the reviled, and the unforgivable. They are the floor beneath which we refuse to let our society sink, no matter how terribly an individual has behaved.

When a law student steps into a prison visiting room, sits across a scratched plexiglass table from a man like Jeffrey Ewert, and opens a notepad, she is performing an act of profound civic maintenance. She is oiling the hinges of a door that must remain able to open, even when we wish it were welded shut. She is ensuring that the government—our government, acting in our name—follows its own rules, keeps its own promises, and exercises its immense power with discipline rather than vengeance.

She does not do it because she likes her client. She does not do it because she lacks empathy for the women whose lives were stolen decades ago. She does it because someone has to hold the line between justice and revenge.

Late at night, long after the news cycle has moved on to the next outrage and the commenters have found a new target, the heavy textbooks remain open on a desk in Montreal. The highlighter caps are off. The work continues, quiet and stubborn, in the shadow of a threat that never should have been made.

NH

Nora Hughes

A dedicated content strategist and editor, Nora Hughes brings clarity and depth to complex topics. Committed to informing readers with accuracy and insight.